|
Reader Comments
I normally am not impressed with "re-recorded" versions of classic songs. But this album is an exception! I would not have believed it but these songs are even better than the original versions! Randy's growth as an artist over the years comes through and his talent has given old songs a fresh approach that makes them even more powerful than the originals! As for the film: It contains what appear to be honest expressions of people who were at one time some of Larry's closest, most intimate friends. What they say is frustrating and it would have been nice to hear Larry's response to it all. But, Wolfgang, Christianity should be about truth--not hiding from the truth. And we will never get at the truth if we do not openly listen to what people have to say. Keeping all of these allegations "undercover" like they have been for years is exactly NOT what Christianity should have done.
Randy Stonehill is one of my all time favourite songwriters (together with Larry Norman, Terry Scott Taylor and Mark Heard). This record is possibly very good. Still to me the original versions of the songs sound much better. And I think is strange to make an(in my opinion very unfair and unfriendly) movie about Larry Norman and use some (rerecorded) songs by Randy Stonehill as a soundtrack. (It is like you would make a movie about Bob Dylan and use the music of Paul Simon as a soundtrack. Very strange.) I also don' t like the idea of making controversial movies about christian musicians. Maybe you can find a lot of pain and broken marriages and mistakes if you look for it but I don't know if this is really the spirit of Jesus who said that you are only allowed to throw stones when you are perfect (without sin). I think in times like today one should make encouraging christian movies and not movies that cause pain and confusion.
Slightly ironic that when Fallen Angel criticises Larry Norman for his spin and self-mythologising we find Randy writing in the linear notes that, despite knowing Larry Norman and his family were 100% against the making of the film, Randy imagines Larry listening approvingly to his album from beyond the grave and giving him a thumbs up for a job well done. Am i the only one who thinks that if indeed Larry made it to heaven (despite being a Fallen Angel) he probably has better things to do with is time than listen to the latest CD releases, and that it is very unlikely given his opposition to the movie in question that he'd be happy to write a blurb recommending we buy the CD?