Simon Dillon gives his opinion on who should have won



Continued from page 1

Oscar Rant 2013

Winner: Jennifer Lawrence - Silver Linings Playbook

My Choice: Quvenzhané Wallis - Beasts Of The Southern Wild. It isn't as great as some have claimed, but the central performance by Quvenzhane Wallis is nothing less than astonishing.

Oscar Rant 2013

Best Supporting Actress:

Winner: Anne Hathaway - Les Misérables.

My Choice: Amy Adams - The Master. I like Anne Hathaway but I'm not a fan of Les Miserables (the musical, at any rate).

Oscar Rant 2013

Best Animated Film:

Winner: Brave

My Choice: Frankenweenie. Actually every other film nominated was better than Brave. A real disappointment.

Oscar Rant 2013

Best Adapted Screenplay:

Winner: Chris Terrio - Argo


My Choice: David Magee - Life Of Pi. With all due respect to Chris Terrio, Life of Pi is a much harder book to turn into a coherent film, let alone an outstanding one.

Oscar Rant 2013

Best Original Screenplay:

Winner: Quentin Tarantino - Django Unchained

My Choice: Rian Johnson - Looper (not nominated). This one really grinds my gears. Any film that messes up its third act as self-indulgently as Django Unchained should not win Best Original Screenplay. As for Rian Johnson's non-nomination, it is nothing less than disgraceful. Looper was an astonishing film that pondered the deep question of exactly what it was that caused someone to turn evil. The fact that it also happens to be a genre piece involving time travel should not disqualify it from consideration. Grrrr..